After knocking out your shopping list, there’s nothing like grabbing a snack before you hit the checkout. Luckily, at Trader Joe’s, there’s no shortage of delicious treats to choose from. You can snag a bag of Irish Butter Potato Chips or opt for Coconut Flavored Almonds. And if you’re craving something sweet, TJ’s shelves are always stocked with craveworthy candy like Sour Strawberry Candy Belts, freeze-dried confections, and unique chocolate bars.
Among all those tempting treats, one Redditor recently discovered a peanut butter-filled cookie at Trader Joe’s—and couldn’t believe they’d missed it before.
Trader Joe’s Chocolate Covered Wafer Cookie With Peanut Butter Filling
In a recent Reddit thread, one user shared a photo of a Trader Joe’s Chocolate Covered Wafer Cookie with Peanut Butter Filling. “I don’t know if this is new, but I wish I had never tried this,” joked the poster. “There’s a hint of sea salt in every bite. It’s quite sweet for my liking, but the salt is giving it a nice balance,” they added.
Allrecipes / Trader Joe’s
You may have overlooked the bar’s orange-toned packaging on shelves, but this treat has actually been a long-standing staple at Trader Joe’s. Each bite is packed with smooth peanut butter filling, crisp wafer cookies, and creamy milk chocolate. The store also carries a peanut butter-free version made with a fudge-like cream instead.
The post’s comment section quickly filled with shoppers who can’t get enough of the decadent treat. “This ticks all my candy bar boxes! Sweet, salty, and crunchy!” said one fan. “I get one pretty much every time I go! It hardly ever makes it home, if it even makes it to the car,” added another.
Some Redditors compared it to other popular peanut butter-filled goodies. “The bar is basically like a big Nutty Bar (Nutty Buddy, as they call them now) or Reese’s Sticks,” said one person in a separate thread.
We have to admit, the wafer bars do look strikingly similar to both of those beloved treats. Considering TJ’s version costs just over a dollar, it’s definitely worth a try. You can typically find Trader Joe’s Chocolate Covered Wafer Cookie with Peanut Butter Filling in the candy section or near the checkout line. So, be sure to sample one on your next shopping trip and see how it stacks up to your usual go-to treat.
